Jump to content

Daniel Hersh

Members
  • Posts

    2,649
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Daniel Hersh

  1. 12 hours ago, Squeezebox Of Delights said:

    The Wren is pretty poor in construction; it is basically everything you’d expect from a cheap Chinese-made instrument. I’ve never had a look inside a Phoenix, but I’d expect that it is much better.
    The Wren has  accordion-type reed blocks, which makes it quite long, while the Phoenix seems more traditional in dimensions, making me think it has flat-mounted reeds.

    The Wren also has nasty fabric/paper/plastic bellows with shallow folds and sharp corners, and they have a habit of collapsing in on themselves when you pull them out too hard. The Phoenix however looks to have more traditionally constructed bellows with rounded corners and leather binding.

    The other main difference I can see is in the actions. The Wren has a Stagi-style aluminium action where all the levers are positioned parallel to each other, but, as hjcjones has already mentioned, the Phoenix has a traditional riveted action radiating out from the buttons.

    All in all, the Phoenix is evidently the better instrument, but it all depends on budget! 

     

    If you want to buy from McNeela, there's also the Swan model which is between the two in price and presumably in quality too.  I have played a Swan and thought it was a decent instrument for the price.

  2. 2 hours ago, Joe Overmyer said:

    Daniel, Yes this is my concertina. Really I do not know the left from the right. I hope if you are interested you will bid.  I believe this is a good price. Joe

     

    Joe - I agree that it's a good price if it's in reasonable playing condition.  But I already have an almost identical concertina, so I don't need another one.

  3. 9 hours ago, emilyconcertina said:

    What do folks think of the Trinity College AP-1130 Anglo-Style Concertina 30b? 

     

    I think it's most likely what's sometimes called a "generic Chinese" or "cheap Chinese" concertina.  Some of them are ok, but they are often poorly made and don't work properly.  If you're looking for a new student/beginner Anglo, I would say you'd be better off with a Wren or a Rochelle. 

  4. 22 hours ago, CMA said:

    Hello all,

     

    (I apologize in advance if this topic has been discussed before)

     

    My husband is looking to get a concertina...he bought one in March but the buttons kept sticking after only 1 day (it was a Bonetti) and he had to return it and the company never replaced it. 

    He is looking to take it on deployment coming up, so it needs to be a very reliable model with a case but something not super expensive since it will be in less than ideal conditions. He has been told that a Trinity College or Roschelle Anglo model would be good, but also heard of the Wren 2. It would also be an added bonus if the company had better customer service in case of issues. 

     

    If any of you could please point me in the right direction I would be very grateful! Thank you!

     

     

    The Wren and the Rochelle are generally considered to be the best of the student/beginner Anglos.

  5. 9 minutes ago, soloduet said:

    Maybe even more lost in translation because I don't know well this music and I didn't want to just make a copy, but after listening to both versions I tried to adapt it on my Wicky duet in the same key of G. For me it's the same tune with 2 big changes in the Tricolor version: the rhythm and a F natural instead of a F sharp in some parts:

    https://youtu.be/jn0IHSOWrZI

     

    https://youtu.be/NlITwrLjUJI

     

     

    Very nice (both versions)!  The Japanese video seems to gone from the Internet now (at any rate, I was unable to find it) so your version of their version may be the only one we've got now.

×
×
  • Create New...