Jump to content

wunks

Members
  • Posts

    837
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by wunks

  1. 4 hours ago, Sebastian said:

    Very nice! I toyed a bit with Paulstretch filters when a tune was to simple. What kind of filters did you use?

     

    @wunks A tromba marina, or how is it called in English?

    Yes.  This appears to be a 17th century version.  lt is bowed, with harmonics struck by the thumb.  Loose translation would be "Mary's Trumpet" as it was a convent instrument, nuns being forbidden to play horns.

  2. A quick click on you-tube shows them both as barn dances .  The clip is of Collin Botts and the comments say as per Cormac Begly.   Mind you, "barn dance" seems to be a catch all term when applied to individual tunes, unlike "hornpipe or "polka".

  3. 26 minutes ago, David Barnert said:

     

    BE the dancers. I have found that experience on the contradance floor is enormously helpful to informing my playing of contradance tunes. I play in a large contradance band (we played a dance last night) and many of the musicians are not dancers. You can hear it in their playing.

     

    Yes, indeed!  A good stomping Balance needs a different feel than a Gypsy or a Hay for Four and if the head couple is waiting out, you should be playing the "B" part.

     

  4. 20 hours ago, scoopet said:

    You're allowed to take one concertina.........what one and why...?

     

    I think I'd bring my wreck of a Lachenal tudor that I've been meaning to restore.....someday.  it's so leaky it would be quite useful in this situation!  It'd make a great fish trap with some slight modification and could be used as a Baleen for sieving out the small organic goodies for making soup.  Assuming the hot/dry alternative, it's black bellows would make it a dandy solar shower and it will provide cooling comfort in the mid-day hours.  It's ubiquitous octagon wooden box has many potential uses.  Among the less discrete;  a pillow, a seat, a means for transporting coconuts (after draining, to keep them from drying out) an abode for one's pet crab.......

     

    Additionally,  the few squawks and groans it does make, could be useful for luring in sea birds and marine mammals looking to mate, with a few frantic box lid claps to disperse them if things get out of hand.......?

  5. 24 minutes ago, Bill N said:

    Since the demise of my Long-Sword Side I have been sitting in with a band that plays for New England style contra dancing.  They play a lot of stuff from the Portland collection, a little bit of Old Time stuff, and quite a bit from contemporary dance tune composers.  It's a fiddle driven band, and they don't like to be confined to G and D Major.  They like the concertina in the mix, and have been pushing me up to the front.  I've been getting the new tunes and fast tempo under my fingers, but have been mostly playing melody or really basic harmonies.  On nights when we don't have a piano, or its just me and the fiddles, I would like to function more as a rhythm instrument, and am looking for ideas on how to tackle it.  I don't read music.  I have 30 button C/G & G/D boxes, a 20 button Bb/F, and a big baritone double reeded 20 button D/A.  I've been making up chord charts, listening hard to the piano player, and wearing out my Jody Kruskal CDs and making some progress, but would welcome any advice.

    Welcome to contra dancing!  Here's my advice; 

     

    -Play for the dancers.  You're not center stage but part of a delightful whole.  To this effect, pay attention to the caller/prompter and refrain from excessive chat and /or exercising your instrument while they're giving instructions.  

    -Even when playing lead you need to drive the rhythm.  Aspire to being able to play the dance all by yourself.  Join the dance with your upper body while playing!

    - As you have mentioned,  contra music is a hodgepodge and each dance desires a unique approach:  marches, reels, polkas, hornpipes, jigs, rags etc. for the longways sets and maybe a hombo or Schottish before the brake, and of course a waltz.  

    -Oom-pa is sometimes appropriate, especially with a sparse band but try to fill empty spaces ( and leave some).  A chug on the back beat really works as does a counter melody in the lower register.  For a waltz, a Swedish beat : 1,2'-1,2'-  works well.

  6. 11 hours ago, alex_holden said:

     

    Normal reeds don't sound when drawing air through them in the wrong direction. I once attempted to make a special bidirectional reed but it wasn't very successful.

    Alex, do you mean the reed it's self or the reed/shoe combination?

  7. I've been thinking along similar lines for my duet to fill some vacant slots, leaning toward the bisonoric solution, however the idea keeps popping into my head of using a single reed for both push and pull thus gaining an extra note.  The only major problem with this that I can think of is that with no valve on the draw the air would tend to push the pad open when the note is not being played.  I'm sure others have considered this.  does anyone have a fix?  I can envision  an entire instrument set up this way:  same # of buttons but half the reeds and valves.  

  8. Thank you Geoff.  This is very helpful in explaining how the pattern of this Wheatstone instrument (sold to me around 1970 by your brother, I have the bill of sale somewhere) was arrived at and instructs me as to how to fill in the vacant reed spaces.  would the Crabb internal layout have been in a radial pattern like the Wheatstone or parallel like the Jeffries?

  9. In "The Man Who Invented Christmas" about Charles Dickens' writing of "A Christmas Carol" the lead engages in a few frustrated squeezes (on an anglo I think) in the first few minutes of the film.  Apologies if this has been posted previously.....?

  10. 2 hours ago, Mikefule said:

    There is no problem with someone buying cheaply, if he does so honestly, and there is no problem with someone selling for the best price he can get.  That is not capitalism, but simply the free market in operation.

     

    What would be morally questionable would be:

     

     1)  Buying cheaply by convincing an elderly and vulnerable widow that a beautiful classic instrument was worth only a tiny amount.  On the other hand, if a person is not vulnerable and they have access to the internet, and they don't do their research, they can't blame the buyer if they don't get a fair price.

     

    2)  Selling at an inflated price to a gullible customer — although, in the main, the customer is primarily to blame for not doing their research.

     

     

    Dishonestly misrepresenting the facts about an instrument or its provenance in order to manipulate the price would be fraud (UK: Fraud Act 2006, section 2) and may in certain cases be theft (Theft Act 1968).

     

    If someone stockpiles large numbers of items so that they personally have an influence on the market, and then they abuse that influence to manipulate prices, that is one of the less desirable aspects of capitalism.

     

    I see no obvious problem with the example that started the thread.  Who among us would not buy cheaply from auction if the opportunity arose?  Who among us would not sell for the best price we could get?  We are all passionate about concertinas here, and perhaps feel differently about it because it is concertinas, but car dealers do it all the time and that is part of life.  No doubt classic car fans feel the same as we do when they see a classic car bought and sold for a quick profit.

    As to #1, I have some friends who deal in oriental rugs and they inform me there are laws here in the U.S. against this practice.  You can't misrepresent either to raise or lower the price and can be sued for fair market value.  On the other hand, a low asking price is fair game.  I personally wouldn't expect to get much of a deal from auction or an online bidding site.  too many eyes on the prize.  Craigslist is a better bet and Facebook has a concertina for sale page.  to my mind estate sales and garage sales etc. are best.  but you need to get to them early.  I don't buy stuff just for speculation but to improve my lot.  I sit with my morning coffee, lap top, and a hand lens and go through craigslist.  Takes about a half an hour for 3 local sites.  lots of people are putting their estates and other sales up with group pics.  With the hand lens I can go through 5 or 6 garage sales in short order from my arm chair.  

  11. 47 minutes ago, accordian said:

    well that's what i meant as well just described slightly differently. some of the reeds i need to put alot more work in  the bellows in order to get any sound and this instruments air leakge is huge so that doesn't help.

     

    I bought this instrument hoping to try out a duet however I think that all I have done is buy a instrument which is in a bit of a wrecked state. 

    I'm facing a similar situation with a pretty rosewood ended Lachenal tutor that I bought right from a friend.  It's a mess.  After a period of "why the heck did I buy this piece of junk?" I started thinking of it's problems individually.  I've never worked on a concertina and have done only minor repairs and adjustments to fiddles, banjos and such.  I began to realize that there are cosmetic issues, mechanical issues.and acoustical issues   To quote my daughter when she was around two years old: " Look, daddy it's a bouquet of motorcycles!".  Setting aside the cosmetic, solve the mechanics and the acoustical problems disappear.

     

  12. I don't know much about music theory or how an anglo is set up but try A minor and E minor (relative minors for C and G).  I know from messing around with a 2 row melodeon trying to play Quebecois music that lots of tunes fit that are not in either full scale row.  You just won't be able to play chromatically in every key.  If your box has some accidentals try playing in those keys and see what fits.

  13. 4 hours ago, soloduet said:

    I like this kind of slow and simple melody on concertina and it's nice to listen to both versions. Don is right when saying that it's difficult to find a good balance between melody and accompaniment on solo concertina, and maybe the problem is more obvious with duet concertinas which are made to play melody and accompaniment together. After talking about this problem of balance with Harry Geuns he gave me some leather baffles to put especially inside the left hand and it's better but not enough. Amplification is another solution but the main interest of the concertina is to be a small and simple instrument, so it would be great if concertinas makers could work on this problem and find acoustic solutions.

    I think any acoustic solution should be internal because the instrument is so beautiful.  What comes to mind is the banjo tone ring.  The examples of concertinas with perforated ends recently shown here don't in my opinion improve the looks of the instrument and aren't constructed like a tone ring.  For an excellent article by Barry Hunn on the function and materials of banjo tone rings see: blog.deeringbanjos.com/what-banjo-tone-rings-do .

×
×
  • Create New...