Jump to content

Dutch Reversal


Recommended Posts

A while ago, I fell in love with a 20-button instrument. But I missed having A/G reversals — so I made my own, by swapping some notes, mostly on the C row.

DutchReverse.thumb.jpg.bb8d60b30e038be1f62608c4ccbead39.jpg

 

I later learned that this is a fairly common move on melodeons, where it's called a "Dutch reversal."

 

I ended up liking it a lot. To be clear, it's terrible for playing in C, and I'm sure it's bad for cross-row Irish. But it's fantastic for other styles:

 

  • Harmonic style in G — it's a total game-changer. Playing morris tunes in G went from being a massive pain in the neck (Jody Kruskal once very politely asked me "Why are you doing this to yourself?") to feeling totally natural.
  • Chris Droney/Frank Edgley style — it's a nice improvement. Your "home row" barely changes and your "helper row" gets a bit more helpful.
  • "House dance" octave playing — it's a nice improvement. The basic technique doesn't change, but a few tricky fingerings get better.  

 

One weird downside of that layout is both G3's are in the same direction. But since I was no longer using the lowest C anyway, I swapped it out and did a little more fiddling to put a push G3 and a pull G3 on the same button. So now I had a drone key, and a free space I could fill by buying a loose reed. I chose a pull E4.

 

ReverseandDrone.thumb.jpeg.1fbd0c08d9a9b25cdb598c9c62c2eba7.jpeg

 

In fact, I like this layout so much that I did the same swaps on my 30-button instrument. I didn't need the reversals, but it's still worth it for the improved fingerings and the way it makes harmonizing in G more convenient. So here's what I'm playing now:

 

image.thumb.png.b1dce50e9a82fda0bc19ace5bce13a76.png

 

Tl;dr: If you like historical Anglo styles, or if you want to play morris tunes in G and Irish tunes in D/G on the same instrument, the Dutch reversal might be for you!

Edited by Leah Velleman
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...