Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Bullethead

Home Repairs For The Jackie Ec

Recommended Posts

This thread is intended for folks like me: total concertina newbies who have recently gotten a Jackie from Concertina Connection. While this box has a good sound and plays easily enough, it does have some durability issues that will manifest themselves after a relatively short time. I've had mine about 2 weeks now, probably putting about 30 hours on it, and already I've had to open it up twice. I suspect that I'm not alone in this, so I'm posting this to give some confidence to those who are afraid to do their own minor repairs.

 

First off, check out this video by Daddy Long Les where he's got his Jackie taken apart. This will show you what's inside better than I can explain it.

 

Now that you're familiar with the general anatomy, here are key details:

  • DO NOT OVER-TIGHTEN THE SCREWS. The wood is all very soft so there's a real threat of stripping threads.
  • USE THE CORRECT SIZE OF SCREWDRIVER. The screw metal is very soft so there's a real threat of wallowing out the heads if your screwdriver is the wrong size or not applied forcefully enough down into the screw.
  • The concertina consists of 3 main assemblies: the central bellows and the 2 nearly identical end assemblies.
  • The end assemblies are each attached to the bellows by 6 small Philips screws and washers, and come off the bellows as units
    • When reassembling the ends to bellows, fasten the screws as you would the lug nuts on a car tire, in a star pattern working them all slightly tighter over several sequences. This is to make sure the end fits evenly and snugly on the bellows. Otherwise you get air leaks through the joint and the concertina won't play well or at all.
  • The end assemblies consist of 2 major parts held together by 2 tiny Philips screws on the underside:
    • The outer black end cap to which the strap and rest are attached
    • The action, which consists of the reeds, valves, buttons, springs, and rocker arms all mounted on 1 big mass of various wood pieces all glued together.
    • Just undo the 2 tiny screws enough to separate the end cap from the action, without removing the screws from the action. This helps prevent losing them.
  • Without the end cap attached, the buttons are free to wobble around and have a tendency to fall off their rocker arms, have their tails come out of their holes, and otherwise not be where they should be. This makes reassembling the end cap to the action a frustrating, fiddly process, the most difficult single thing in the whole process. Fortunately, the buttons all seem to be identical so if several fall completely off, it shouldn't matter which rocker you put them back on.
  • The ends of the thumb straps are held in place by a knob that screws into the edge of the end cap. To adjust the strap, unscrew and remove this knob, stick it through a different hole in the strap, and screw it back into the end cap.

TOOLS:

  • Jewelers Philips screwdrivers of several sizes
  • Needlenose pliers
  • Tweezers
  • Magnifying lens or glasses (depending on your eyesight)
  • Lok-Tite or similar product to keep nuts on bolts

 

COMMON PROBLEMS

 

1. Straps or Rests Coming Loose

The straps and rests are attached to the end caps by tiny countersunk Philips screws with nuts and washers on the inside. These nuts tend to loosen or come off completely. When the nuts come off, they will rattle around inside the action but can be shaken out the sound holes. Be careful not to lose them.

 

To fix: Remove the end with the loose part from the bellows. Remove the end cap from the action. Reassemble the strap/rest fasteners using Lok-Tite. While you're in there, tighten up and apply Lok-Tite to all other strap/rest fasteners so you don't have to do this again. Getting a screwdriver on the strap screws will require unscrewing the strap-adjustment knob.

 

2. Stretching Straps

The thumb straps are made from some very cheap fake leather, basically a roll of vinyl with some spongy white fabric inside. This quickly stretches, especially if you play with the concertina on your knee and only move 1 end of it routinely. If you're already on the last hole provided and the strap is too loose, poke a new hole with an ice pick. You don't want or need a very big hole because the strap knob's shaft is only a couple millimeters wide.

 

OTHER POINTS

 

The rocker arms can easily pivot side-to-side as well as up-and-down. Thus, when finagling the buttons into proper formation for reassembling the end cap to the action, it's possible that pushing a button sideways will push its valve the same amount in the opposite direction, which can cause the valve not to completely cover its hole. So before putting the cap back on, be sure all the valves are properly covering their holes.

 

Once you've managed to get the end cap back over all the buttons at once and have the action seated fully into the end cap, you can no longer see any of the action nor even the holes and valves. Therefore, before screwing the end cap back onto the action, test each button for proper springiness. If it springs back up and stays straight, then it's on its rocker arm OK and all SHOULD be well (unless you've moved a valve sideways, which you can't see). If the button has no spring, then you have to take the end cap back off and put the button back on its rocker arm.

 

It's a good idea to only remove 1 end assembly from the bellows at a time. This way, you can be sure you put the end back on the bellows with the same orientation as before. This is important because the screw holes don't line up if you've rotated the end assembly relative to the bellows. If you must remove both ends at once, apply some masking tape to the bellows ends where the thumb straps go, so you can properly orient the end assemblies when you put them back on. Also write on the masking tape which end is left and right.

 

As mentioned above, make sure there are no gaps between the end assembly and the bellows. When reattaching the end assembly, get all the screws in the end assembly until their tips are flush with the bottom of the end cap before placing the assembly on the bellows. Make sure the end cap is oriented correctly and then partially tighten all the screws in a star pattern as with lug nuts until fully seated.

 

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One thing I've found really convenient when reassembling Stagi concertinas, when some buttons just won't slide into their hole as I place the end on: I use the eraser end of a mechanical pencil, since it "grips" the plastic really well, making it easier to slide the button a bit to the side to slide into the hole, when normal tools just can't get a purchase on the slick surface.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's a good idea, Matt. If, God forbid, I have to get back in my Jackie, I'll remember it. One help with the Jackie is that that the buttons are domed so you only really need to get them slightly more than 1/2way properly aligned, not dead-nuts perfect, and they'll self-center. But OTOH they're also loose enough on their rockers that any contact is likely to make them swing too far the other way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't find it now, but somewhere (perhaps on one of Bob Tedrow's vanished repair/building pages), a photo showed a flat wood template with correct holes for all the buttons. Use this to line them up, lift off carefully (like racking up billiard balls for american-style pool) and the fretwork end goes right on. If you disassemble a concertina a lot (or become a repair person), the time saved would eventually justify the effort of making the template(s).

 

Ken

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Howdy Ken-

 

Yeah, it's occurred to met that some sort of jig or "pool rack" as you say would be a big help. I just haven't envisioned a good way of making one that isn't as difficult to put on itself as the actual end cap. I figure it would help to countersink the undersides of the holes so the buttons would funnel into the correct position as you lowered the template.

 

I guess next time (which hopefully won't be any time soon) I open my box up, I'll make a pattern off the holes in the end caps. That way I can make the tool at my leisure so it will be ready for the time after that. When I've had to get into my Jackie so far, it's because strap nuts have come off during playing, so I was just wanting to get it back going ASAP to keep playing. I'm afraid of leaving the thing sitting there disassembled for any time due to fear of curious cats ;).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Something that has worked for me both with a Rochelle and a wobbly buttoned Lachenal is to hold the concertina "up-side-down" so that the buttons are hanging down, and raise the end up to the buttons. The buttons seem to centre themselves and don't flop around. With a little bit of side-to-side wiggling of the end cap the buttons can be jiggled into their respective holes.

Edited by Bill N

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Something that has worked for me both with a Rochelle and a wobbly buttoned Lachenal is to hold the concertina "up-side-down" so that the buttons are hanging down, and raise the end up to the buttons. The buttons seem to centre themselves and don't flop around. With a little bit of side-to-side wiggling of the end cap the buttons can be jiggled into their respective holes.

 

That sounds like a good idea. However, at least with my particular Jackie, this would require some care with the left end, where many of the rocker arms only stick a few millimeters beyond their holes in the button stems. Thus, tipping the action unit in most directions causes the buttons to fall off the arms.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As Bullethead notes, the ends of these concertinas are held in with 6 long wood screws at each end.

 

Not the greatest idea. You can only remove and refit the ends a limited number of times before the threads in the wood are wrecked.

 

There are a few things that you can do to greatly increase their longevity.

 

First, overdrill the holes in the ends so that the screws do not bind in them. They should be drilled out to a size that just allows you to easily push a screw all of the way in without having to screw it in. These holes are much too small on stock instruments.

 

When screwing the ends back on, gently push the screw in until you feel contact with the frame then slowly unscrew the screw while very gently pushing it in until you feel a slight click. You have just found the beginning of the threaded hole in the wooden frame. Now screw it most of the way in, but not all of the way in. Do the same thing with the other 5 screws. Now, pick a screw and with your hand squeeze the end and the frame together aound the screw while you tighten the screw until it is just snug in the frame. Do not crank it! Now do the same thing with screw that is diametrically opposite the one that you have just done. Then do the remaining two pairs of screws the same way, always tightening opposing screws. Finally, go back to the first screw that you put in, squeeze the end and frame together with your fingers as tightly as you can and try to snug the screw in a little more but do not crank it, just tighten it. Do the same thing with all of the other screws in the same order that you did before. This may seem a bit of a laborious procedure, but it is not really that bad.

 

Don.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×