Rose Of Raby - Ec Vs. Melodeon

[Wolf Molkentin]

In case somebody should be interested, as I was learning this wonderful tune by Dave Shepherd simultaneously on both instruments:

 

here's Rose of Raby

 

(in order to be compared with the melodeon version)

 

Best wishes - Wolf

[John Adey]

A great tune that is a real 'ear worm' for me.

Very nice arrangement on the EC.

[Bob Michel]

simultaneously on both instruments

Bravo. You've inspired me to appreciative larceny. A C#/D box (the only two-row I currently play) has its own quirky ideas about the tune, though:

 

http://youtu.be/6szcgIs3BhE

 

And on concertina:

 

http://youtu.be/5NG5wpwR83A

 

Bob Michel

Near Philly

Edited July 16, 2015 by Bob Michel

[Wolf Molkentin]

Thanks a lot Bob,

 

I by no means pictured this - it is true, sort of culpable, but nevertheless more than justified - widening the new thread...

 

Two great versions from your side!

 

And John, thank you much as well for listening, I'm very glad about your appreciative comment on my EC arrangement!

 

Best wishes - Wolf

[Chris Drinkwater]

Lovely version on the tina, Wolf. You've certainly got the arrangement nicely buttoned up! And not bad on the melodeon, either.

 

 

Chris

[Wolf Molkentin]

(unintended double-post)

Edited July 19, 2015 by blue eyed sailor

[Wolf Molkentin]

Thanks a lot Chris! I really appreciate your listening to both recordings and affirmative resp. encouraging words!

 

Best wishes - Wolf