Stephen Chambers Posted April 7, 2011 Share Posted April 7, 2011 I thought that Dan Worrall had already demonstrated convincingly that concertinas did go to sea? Is anybody saying that they didn't? But the image might seem to some of us a tired (and rather unjustified) cliché, in that sailors have played lots of other instruments too... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dave Rogers Posted April 7, 2011 Share Posted April 7, 2011 Is anybody saying that they didn't? I thought Chris Timson sounded a little unsure: "true enough, but then if concertinas did go to sea" Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fiddlehead Fern Posted April 7, 2011 Share Posted April 7, 2011 (edited) At least one concertina has gone sailing on all five of the Great Lakes on a square-rigger in recent years, and lived to tell the tale. I hear objections to the salty sea air, now, I've not done any ocean sailing, but from my experiences on large vessels belowdecks is quite dry, and, for the most part, comparable to living in a house on land. (If you lived in very close quarters with your housemates and didn't bathe often, that is.) Sailors seem to be a rather misrepresented lot in general though. Most anyone who sees a sailing vessel of any description immediately thinks "PIRATE SHIP!!!" and resists any attempts made by the crew of such a vessel to educate them on the actual history of it. (Which, for the overwhelming majority, is not a storied history of mermaids and cutlass-swinging rogues.) I figure that "every Jack Tar played a funny little round accordion" is one of the last notions I'll try to wipe out of their brains, since assuring them that the ship isn't actually on an underwater track, and yes, we actually use the sails takes priority. P.S. Solas plays a tune called "Vital Mental Medicine" on their CD For Love and Laughter. Hmmm. P.P.S. I play concertina no matter what mood I'm in, usually if I'm going to channel emotions by making noise I reach for the 'tina before the fiddle, because it's easier to just fool around with and experiment with different sounds on. Edited April 7, 2011 by Fiddlehead Fern Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dan Worrall Posted April 7, 2011 Share Posted April 7, 2011 Is anybody saying that they didn't? I thought Chris Timson sounded a little unsure: "true enough, but then if concertinas did go to sea" Yikes! Not this debate again!!! I thought I had driven a stake into its heart! Chris seems to perhaps doubt that concertinas went to sea, and more certainly that quality ones did not:true enough, but then if concertinas did go to sea (a subject that has given rise to much discussion on this forum in the past) then it wouldn't have been someone's loved and valuable Jeffries or Wheatstone but one of the German concertinas so widely and cheaply available at that time. My article (http://angloconcertina.org/research_articles.html) gave plenty of information of not only German concertinas at sea but also Wheatstones, Jeffries, Jones and Lachenal..... At the time I wrote it, there seemed to be a feeling that they weren't at sea...and I provided quotes from John Kirkpatrick and the head of a USA whaling museum. My conclusion was that its image as a key (though not the only) seaborne instrument was quite justified, but that it was the Hollywood and British cartoon images --and the long gap in actual playing of the instrument--that gave people doubts. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rod Thompson Posted April 8, 2011 Share Posted April 8, 2011 Always amused by the vast number of folds cartoonists give tina bellows. Reminds me of Geoff Crabb's story of the skipping rope concertina. Chris But we have conclusive proof that frogs play concertinas with vast numbers of folds. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Theo Posted May 8, 2011 Share Posted May 8, 2011 Is anybody saying that they didn't? I thought Chris Timson sounded a little unsure: "true enough, but then if concertinas did go to sea" Yikes! Not this debate again!!! I thought I had driven a stake into its heart! Chris seems to perhaps doubt that concertinas went to sea, and more certainly that quality ones did not:true enough, but then if concertinas did go to sea (a subject that has given rise to much discussion on this forum in the past) then it wouldn't have been someone's loved and valuable Jeffries or Wheatstone but one of the German concertinas so widely and cheaply available at that time. My article (http://angloconcertina.org/research_articles.html) gave plenty of information of not only German concertinas at sea but also Wheatstones, Jeffries, Jones and Lachenal..... At the time I wrote it, there seemed to be a feeling that they weren't at sea...and I provided quotes from John Kirkpatrick and the head of a USA whaling museum. My conclusion was that its image as a key (though not the only) seaborne instrument was quite justified, but that it was the Hollywood and British cartoon images --and the long gap in actual playing of the instrument--that gave people doubts. Here is a concertina on ebay with a link to a sailor. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now