Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I can't hear any sound ( did they have sound then or was it a silent film?) do you mean from the fingering. Looks liek a C whistle , Clarkes?

 

 

The first link in this thread takes you to a clip with sound & a concertina player. There is a soundless "out take" reel with a whistle player. The box player makes generous use of the "doppler effect" in his playing.

Posted

I can't hear any sound ( did they have sound then or was it a silent film?) do you mean from the fingering. Looks liek a C whistle , Clarkes?

I heard it OK, but I recognize neither the tune nor the concertina player.

Posted

Thanks i missed it!

 

the player is on Anglo and sounds a lively and accomplshed player.

 

The march on tune sounds like a march in Eb or Bb , we used to sing some jingostic words we were taught at school as a kid in Manchester in the 40s about Britannia's Family Tree to the song a also a bit like the tune from the ABC cinemas Saturday matineed later on.

 

 

the jig is in Am and seems along the middle row of a C/G ( anyone worked out how many buttons it has?) It sounds related to Tenpenny Bit which is still played for rapper dances. Not necessarily Irish although there were quite a few Irish settled in the mining areas of the NE. Similar tunes were played on fiddle and can be found in tune books from the 18th C onwards.

Posted

I can't hear any sound ( did they have sound then or was it a silent film?) do you mean from the fingering. Looks liek a C whistle , Clarkes?

 

I found the sound on the clip in the original post to be VERY quiet, I could just about hear it at full volume - try setting the amp to 11 :lol:

(then I blasted my eardrums later on, since I'd forgotten to wind it back down)

Posted

They used an extract form that fil set against some current rapper dancers on BBC 4 Unthank sidters' programme last night.

 

Clog dancing tonight!

Best nights TV for a long time .Especially as they featured our own Penzance Golowan Band with Penglaze.Bob

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...