up-fiddler Posted July 27, 2010 Share Posted July 27, 2010 A question for those who are in the know concertina-wise. I purchased a new Morse Anglo in G/D a month and a half ago. I have played it about an hour daily since then. While at a fiddle festival last week I was practicing in the afternoon of a very hot and humid day. The sound seemed thinner than usual and then one reed suddenly didn't sound but just a tiny bit. (B above high G) Afraid that I had ruined my new pride and joy I put her away immediately rather than forcing any more air through her and possibly damaging something. The following day was cooler and drier so I tried each button (Push and Draw) very gingerly to see if everything was all right. Then I played it a bit louder for a few tunes. To my surprise the Morse now had a pleasant low end 'growl' and some very deep overtones. It has continued to this day. I swear that I am not imagining it but wish I had an earlier recording of it to compare against how she sounds now. My question - (Finally!) Do concertinas 'play in' similar to violins and guitars over time and sound a bit looser and warmer? I honestly believe that it sounds and plays better now than it did before. Then again, I am new to Anglos and my technique could be improving without me being conscious of it. (Prior to this I played diatonic accordions and Chemnitzers.) I have played her hard since and don't seem to find anything wrong with it at all. I just think it suddenly sounds better. Am I daft? Dave Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bill N Posted July 27, 2010 Share Posted July 27, 2010 A question for those who are in the know concertina-wise. I purchased a new Morse Anglo in G/D a month and a half ago. I have played it about an hour daily since then. While at a fiddle festival last week I was practicing in the afternoon of a very hot and humid day. The sound seemed thinner than usual and then one reed suddenly didn't sound but just a tiny bit. (B above high G) Afraid that I had ruined my new pride and joy I put her away immediately rather than forcing any more air through her and possibly damaging something. The following day was cooler and drier so I tried each button (Push and Draw) very gingerly to see if everything was all right. Then I played it a bit louder for a few tunes. To my surprise the Morse now had a pleasant low end 'growl' and some very deep overtones. It has continued to this day. I swear that I am not imagining it but wish I had an earlier recording of it to compare against how she sounds now. My question - (Finally!) Do concertinas 'play in' similar to violins and guitars over time and sound a bit looser and warmer? I honestly believe that it sounds and plays better now than it did before. Then again, I am new to Anglos and my technique could be improving without me being conscious of it. (Prior to this I played diatonic accordions and Chemnitzers.) I have played her hard since and don't seem to find anything wrong with it at all. I just think it suddenly sounds better. Am I daft? Dave My Morse G/D initially had some slight "buzzes" and "gurgles" in the lower notes. They disappeared after a few weeks' playing. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
m3838 Posted July 27, 2010 Share Posted July 27, 2010 A question for those who are in the know concertina-wise. I purchased a new Morse Anglo in G/D a month and a half ago. I have played it about an hour daily since then. While at a fiddle festival last week I was practicing in the afternoon of a very hot and humid day. The sound seemed thinner than usual and then one reed suddenly didn't sound but just a tiny bit. (B above high G) Afraid that I had ruined my new pride and joy I put her away immediately rather than forcing any more air through her and possibly damaging something. The following day was cooler and drier so I tried each button (Push and Draw) very gingerly to see if everything was all right. Then I played it a bit louder for a few tunes. To my surprise the Morse now had a pleasant low end 'growl' and some very deep overtones. It has continued to this day. I swear that I am not imagining it but wish I had an earlier recording of it to compare against how she sounds now. My question - (Finally!) Do concertinas 'play in' similar to violins and guitars over time and sound a bit looser and warmer? I honestly believe that it sounds and plays better now than it did before. Then again, I am new to Anglos and my technique could be improving without me being conscious of it. (Prior to this I played diatonic accordions and Chemnitzers.) I have played her hard since and don't seem to find anything wrong with it at all. I just think it suddenly sounds better. Am I daft? Dave Could hot air expand reeds more than reed shoes so tongues started to touch the slot walls? Or that the wooden walls swelled and compressed the brass shoes, narrowing the slots? Could it be that reed tongues beating against the slot sides shifted to more central positions and now are set better? But I guarantee that good 80% of the differences in sound are heard only by you. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bill N Posted July 27, 2010 Share Posted July 27, 2010 Could hot air expand reeds more than reed shoes so tongues started to touch the slot walls? Or that the wooden walls swelled and compressed the brass shoes, narrowing the slots? Could it be that reed tongues beating against the slot sides shifted to more central positions and now are set better? But I guarantee that good 80% of the differences in sound are heard only by you. Not in this case. The Morse uses accordion reeds. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ken_Coles Posted July 27, 2010 Share Posted July 27, 2010 The people who know more about this than anyone, I'm sure, are Doug Creighton and Bob Snope at the BBox shop. Why not call them? They'll tell you what others have reported, and I can verify they will fix anything that is wrong if you can't or if it doesn't fix itself. You even go to the head of their usually long repair line! Ken Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
m3838 Posted July 27, 2010 Share Posted July 27, 2010 Could hot air expand reeds more than reed shoes so tongues started to touch the slot walls? Or that the wooden walls swelled and compressed the brass shoes, narrowing the slots? Could it be that reed tongues beating against the slot sides shifted to more central positions and now are set better? But I guarantee that good 80% of the differences in sound are heard only by you. Not in this case. The Morse uses accordion reeds. Aluminum also expands. If it expands more than steel, the gaps will widen and sound thin and weaken. Etc. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Chris Timson Posted July 28, 2010 Share Posted July 28, 2010 (edited) My Morse G/D has never shown any change even when played in the hot weather we so rarely get in England . I am unable to say if it improved from new since it was a demonstrator I bought off Chris Algar and so had been through a few hands before mine. It's been a good, reliable Morris instrument. Chris Edited July 28, 2010 by Chris Timson Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
david_boveri Posted July 30, 2010 Share Posted July 30, 2010 concertinas do indeed break in over time. whether or not they can change overnight i am not sure. i swear that my instrument sounds different after playing during a hot day just 2 days ago, as well. however, this could be that i became used to how it sounded outside, and now it sounds different inside (although it is the same as before). sometimes, when i change acoustical environments, i notice characteristics of the sound that i did not notice before when returning to my usual environment. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ken_Coles Posted July 30, 2010 Share Posted July 30, 2010 My C/G Morse was practically new when I bought it. It was a bit brash then and has definitely mellowed in a bit. I should probably add that note to the review I have posted on the C.net static pages, since there are links to it. Ken Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
up-fiddler Posted August 2, 2010 Author Share Posted August 2, 2010 My C/G Morse was practically new when I bought it. It was a bit brash then and has definitely mellowed in a bit. I should probably add that note to the review I have posted on the C.net static pages, since there are links to it. Ken Mine is behaving similarly and I absolutely love her! A special thanks to all who responded. It seems as though I am continually in debt to the fine folks at this forum. Kudos all around, Dave. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SqeezerGeezer Posted August 2, 2010 Share Posted August 2, 2010 The older Morse (both English and Anglo) sound mellower and sweeter to me than the new ones. Whether this is due to aging or a difference in the concertinas to begin with I don'lt know, but I have tried them side by side in the same room, and there is a definite difference. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rod Posted August 3, 2010 Share Posted August 3, 2010 The older Morse (both English and Anglo) sound mellower and sweeter to me than the new ones. Whether this is due to aging or a difference in the concertinas to begin with I don'lt know, but I have tried them side by side in the same room, and there is a definite difference. I believe that it is generally accepted that a new, decent quality concertina requires some very considerable 'running-in' before it starts operating to it's full potential. This was my not altogether surprising experience. Increasing familiarity with the instrument obviously played a part but there is far more to it than that. The tone and action of the instrument improved immeasurably as the years went by, or so it seemed to me, thereby proving the true benefits of regular exercise, coupled with the occasional dose of sensible maintenance. I try to apply the same principles to myself but cannot claim to have achieved the same degree of success ! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.