okie this is about as belated a reply as there could be. But xmas carols are a bit of a passion of mine
I've been playing the tin whistle just over a year now and spent the best part of the last three months of last year learning carols to play on christmas day. Here in scandinavia people dance round the tree and sing - if you've seen bergmans film "fany and alexander" you get the idea. My wife's family tend not to so much dance as sidestep slowly round the tree after 1/2 an hour of trying to get out of it.
Couple of years ago I introduced some christmas carols in english to the family without any accomanyment and it was a riot - mostly me getting melodies mixed up.
So this time round I bought along my whistles, high d, high c and low d and c.
Bear with me I'm getting to the point and back to the topic
So I played a few danish carols and a few english and made everyone stand still. At the end of each song there was a prize for worst and best singer...
At one point they wanted to take a break so I played few a through songs on my own. Up til then silent night had been my favourite on the low whistle, I tend to play a melancholic version. But as I was flipping through the book of carols I had with me I came across "it came upon the midnight clear" and "god rest you merry gentlemen".
Ofcourse I knew these carols quite well but I'd never really thought about the music. So whistle wise the three above mentioned are my favourites.
I'm looking forward to seeing what if anything I can do with my jackie when it arrives and these three songs will be some of my first attempts.