Jump to content

sqzbxr

Members
  • Posts

    215
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by sqzbxr

  1. Wolf, it's not Jim's job to pat anyone on the back. His responsibility is to organize the tunes and themes for each month, do the polling, create the new threads, etc. Otherwise, he's just like any other member and has the right to comment or not comment on any post, including submissions here. If you're upset that he has commented on both of my meager submissions, you should be aware of two things: 1) Jim has been trying to get me to contribute to TotM for about a year and a half - ever since I became active here again; 2) Jim and I have known each other personally for about 15 years and have played together many times, we have several dozen mutual friends in the U.S. Morris, Contra, English Country, and folk dance scene.

     

    Your initial post on this subject really comes across as a personal attack, or at least a public shaming. It does not do you any justice and unfortunately has lowered your standing in my eyes. You state that Jim's failure to personally acknowledge your individual submissions has made you question wether you should continue with TotM. In light of that, let me ask you this: what effect do you think your public shaming of Jim has had on him? What if he no longer feels justified in organizing the Tune of the Month?

     

    I have to say that I'd rather lose the postings of one member, no matter how enjoyable, than lose the TotM - which Jim has worked so hard to bring about.

  2. Direct link to the PDF for Polka de l'Ase:

     

    http://www.fichier-pdf.fr/2014/06/25/polka-de-l-ase/polka-de-l-ase.pdf

     

     

    For those who prefer ABC:

     

    X:1

    T: Polka de l'Ase

    C: Version J. Vayssade & M. Bernard

    L: 1/16

    M: 2/4

    K: G

    D2|:B2>^A B2>G|A2E2 E4|A4 B2A2|GFGA B2D2|

    B2>^A B2>G|A2E2 E4|A2BA G2F2|1G6 D2:|2G6 d2|

    |:B2d2 G2d2|cdcB A2d2|c2d2 A2e2|dedB d2d2|

    B2d2 G2d2|cdcB A2d2|cdcB A2B2|1G6 d2:|2G6 D2|

    |:B2>^A B2>G|A2E2 E4|A4 B2A2|GFGA B2D2|

    B2>^A B2>G|A2E2 E4|A2BA G2F2|1G6 D2:|2G6 FG|

    K: D

    |:A2A2 A2B2|ABAF A2d2|c2dc B2G2|B4 A2FG|

    A2A2 A2B2|ABAF A2d2|c2dc B2c2|1d6 FG:|2d6 d2|

    K: G

    c2>A c2e2|d2>B d2AB|c2dc B2A2|G6 D2|

    |:B2>^A B2>G|A2E2 E4|A4 B2A2|GFGA B2D2|

    B2>^A B2>G|A2E2 E4|A2BA G2F2|1G6 D2:|2G6|]

  3. In reply to Jim Lucas my ' wildly speculative nonsense ' as he chooses to call it was simply a personal opinion which I felt entitled to express.

     

    Absolutely correct - you ran your theory up the flagpole of public opinion and he saluted as he saw fit. He appears to have provided us with much more meat for his refutation than you have for your speculation. Care to provide more details?

     

    Rod, on 24 Jul 2014 - 3:15 PM, said:snapback.png

    I have never held an English and have never even been curious to do so. I was suspicious of what I read about the English system but the Anglo was love at first sight. I wonder if the English system is more attractive to those into musical theory and dots on paper, aspects of music which I can happily live without. Is there anyone out there who plays both systems ? I doubt it.

    Here again pure speculation on a system (and those who play it) in the same paragraph where you freely admit to having zero personal experience with it! I'm finding it pretty difficult to take you seriously at all based upon these two posts... :rolleyes:
  4. ...I doubt whether Wheatstone ever envisaged the instrument as a component of group or band playing.

     

    Care to elaborate on your sources for this, or is it just more speculation on your part? One really has to wonder why concertinas were made in so many different ranges if they were meant to be only played as an unaccompanied solo instrument.

  5. I have never held an English and have never even been curious to do so. I was suspicious of what I read about the English system but the Anglo was love at first sight. I wonder if the English system is more attractive to those into musical theory and dots on paper, aspects of music which I can happily live without. Is there anyone out there who plays both systems ? I doubt it.

     

    I play both systems, no problem. I have played Anglo for nearly 20 years and switched to English a few months ago. My motivation for doing so was the desire to play classical music and not playing for Morris any more. I have adapted to the English system relatively quickly and painlessly, certainly a much less steep learning curve than the Anglo was. I play both systems by ear and by written music.

  6. An organ score for March from Scipio is available in PDF format here:

     

    http://imslp.org/wiki/Scipione,_HWV_20_(Handel,_George_Frideric)

     

    Use the index on the left - score is public domain.

     

    A direct link to the PDF is here:

     

    http://javanese.imslp.info/files/imglnks/usimg/4/4b/IMSLP318806-PMLP44850-haendel_hwv_020_scipio_marsch.pdf

     

    ABC is available here:

     

    http://abcnotation.com/tunePage?a=www.village-music-project.org.uk/abc/clare_J/0060

×
×
  • Create New...