QUOTE
I am in Montreal and looking for a concertina that I can try before buying.
I have been asking around and everyone reacts as if I'm from another planet ... Concertina ??? ...
Played piano when I was very young, never played anything else, fell in love with the accordeon but can't play it, so I'm thinking this might be my kind of machine.
Can you suggest anything?
I'm not Azalin, but your question is worth of taking on.
Please, reconsider accordion. What do you mean "I can't play it"? Did you expect to play it immediately just because you played piano as a child?
Concertina is NOT a portable cute accordion, it has very distinctive sound, and if you like accordion, chances are you may NOT like concertina. Concertinas are way more expensive, pretty much impossible to try before buying, and the only decent entry level is Jackie/Rochelle, that you take or leave. But any next step upgrade will price-shock you.
Or get as many concertina CDs as possible and listen a few times through (f you haven't done so already, off course).
Others will advice you on players and performers of every possible style.
My personal take is that aside from Irish traditional, concertina playing doesn't come close to accordion school, so you really really have to like the sound
that much.
It's like falling for the Guitar, but learning Ukulele instead.