What our concertinas look like?
#1
Posted 04 March 2012 - 11:48 AM
TTC
Tony two concertinas LOL
#2
Posted 04 March 2012 - 03:46 PM
I remember the first outing of the MV Augusta F4 at the motorcycle show
And I thought then I must be getting old as a pretty half naked girl was draped over the bike and I remember being irritated as she was blocking my view of the wonderful exhaust system LOL
Tony
Ps I’ve been playing the concertinas side by side and I am very surprised at how different they sound ,the rosewood that I thought was warm seems sort of “harsh” but in a really nice throaty way and the action is very positive but requires a little pressure, the ebony raised ends sounds completely different its a mellow and warm sound a bit like its slightly compressed ,very smooth and the action is incredibly light it’s not quite as loud as the rosewood it also has 6 fold bellows opposed to the 5 fold on the rosewood but I can’t see how that wound actually make a difference to the sound or does it?
tony
#4
Posted 04 March 2012 - 04:19 PM
#5
Posted 05 March 2012 - 04:00 AM
Hi Guys sorry if that post appears almost “boastful” but it was not intended as “look at what I’ve bought “I’m just delighted to have found an instrument that can effectively replace the violin and guitar that I’m now unable to play because of my wrist injury and I seem to have developed almost an obsession for everything concertina based and would love to see some pictures of the members concertinas (that sounds a little sleazy LOL)
I remember the first outing of the MV Augusta F4 at the motorcycle show
And I thought then I must be getting old as a pretty half naked girl was draped over the bike and I remember being irritated as she was blocking my view of the wonderful exhaust system LOL
Tony
Ps I’ve been playing the concertinas side by side and I am very surprised at how different they sound ,the rosewood that I thought was warm seems sort of “harsh” but in a really nice throaty way and the action is very positive but requires a little pressure, the ebony raised ends sounds completely different its a mellow and warm sound a bit like its slightly compressed ,very smooth and the action is incredibly light it’s not quite as loud as the rosewood it also has 6 fold bellows opposed to the 5 fold on the rosewood but I can’t see how that wound actually make a difference to the sound or does it?
tony
I would think that whilst the Rosewood ends are probably solid rosewood the Ebony ends are ebonised Pearwood, or something like that. The Rosewood, being a much denser material than the ebonised wood, will give a brighter/ louder tone to the instrument. But each concertina, and those from different periods especially, might show individual sound characteristics .
Geoff.
#6
Posted 05 March 2012 - 06:35 AM
Hi Geoff I thought it was probably a stained hardwood as I use a lot of Gaboon /Macassar ebony in restorations and at around 3mm thickness its liable to shake
But I’ve been having a closer inspection of the ends with a super bright LED light I have in the workshop (eyes aren’t what they used to be LOL) and there are just visible slight dark brown seams?
I often use a stain if it’s not completely black on ebony fingerboards to cover the grey/brown seams and the ends also have that characteristic polish grain look and feel
I think it may possibly be ebony cross laminated? as in one corner it has a slight visible line on the sloping /undulation if this makes sense, it’s also very heavy in comparison to my rosewood one LOL but the light touch buttons are absolutely brilliant and although the reeds respond pretty much at the same speed it’s so much easier to play
I bought the raised ends one as I really want to learn more about the mechanics/acoustics ETC and I did bid on a couple of ebay fixer uppers and then I tried a Lachenal bone button version but I figured I’ll learn more from a well made quality instrument and I am intending to make one ,so it’s the perfect pattern to have the only problem at the moment is a slight “don’t know how to describe it” flabby short flutter? Just before the low G sounds on the push ?
And Geoff many thanks for your help and advice
1910 and 1928 LOL
Tony
#7
Posted 05 March 2012 - 08:22 AM
The other picture shows the three Wheatstones that I play; Baritone/treble Aeola EC 1927. 57key MacCann Aeola 1916 and 48key Treble ("The Mean Green Machine") 1898.
Edited by Geoff Wooff, 05 March 2012 - 08:30 AM.
#8
Posted 05 March 2012 - 11:36 AM

Edited to add: Although the boxes are different sizes, the spacing and slant of the keys and their relationship to the handrest is the same.
Edited by David Barnert, 05 March 2012 - 11:38 AM.
#9
Posted 05 March 2012 - 04:03 PM

Shame I can't play it yet!
Andrew
#10
Posted 05 March 2012 - 05:30 PM
Hey folks, why just the "pretty" ones?Hi Guys and Girls the “What we all look like “topic was very interesting So I thought we could have a similar “what do our concertinas look like” Its a complete coincidence I happen to have bought a beautiful wheatstone raised ebony ends this morning
I expect it'll be quite some time before I get this one restored. Still, it is one of mine.
#11
Posted 05 March 2012 - 05:53 PM
With the advent of this thread in the last couple of days he has agreed to do so. This means the thread will stay at the top of the thread list along with "Current makes of concertina".
Not sure if he will pin this one or start another; my preference would be to pin this one but change its title to something more directly explanatory of the thread purpose. Perhaps "Pictures of your concertina", or "Your concertina photos", something with a noun pertaining to images in the title (apologies to the OP, nothing wrong with your title but the new one might be at the top of the thread list for years)
A big thanks to Paul for this, if like me you don't see many different concertinas year in and year out then this thread is a wonderful opportunity. There are space issues, but Paul has said he will cross that bridge when he gets to it.
Chris
#12
Posted 05 March 2012 - 06:09 PM
What do contributors think - pretty and restored concertinas, or along with those currently awaiting restoration?I recently asked Paul Schwartz if we could have a permanently pinned thread with the subject "Pictures of your concertina".
With the advent of this thread in the last couple of days he has agreed to do so. This means the thread will stay at the top of the thread list along with "Current makes of concertina".
Not sure if he will pin this one or start another; my preference would be to pin this one but change its title to something more directly explanatory of the thread purpose. Perhaps "Pictures of your concertina", or "Your concertina photos", something with a noun pertaining to images in the title (apologies to the OP, nothing wrong with your title but the new one might be at the top of the thread list for years)
A big thanks to Paul for this, if like me you don't see many different concertinas year in and year out then this thread is a wonderful opportunity. There are space issues, but Paul has said he will cross that bridge when he gets to it.
Chris
I'd like to see both restored and restoration candidates.
#13
Posted 06 March 2012 - 02:19 AM
I suspect that different folks will have different desires of what they want to see or show.What do contributors think - pretty and restored concertinas, or along with those currently awaiting restoration?
I'd like to see both restored and restoration candidates.
- Is it just to let others know what we have (bragging rights, perhaps?)?
- Is it to show the variety of structure and design, or the artistry of the makers? In that case, why limit it to our own instruments? (Storage space could be a problem, but we could approach that limit even with just our own instruments.)
- Is it to show how much beauty one can find in different views of concertinas, even in elements not intended as "art"... e.g., not just ends and bellows papers, but the beauty-in-function of interior views?
- An "editor's desk" of submissions for potential inclusion in the concertina coffee table book proposed elsewhere?
Maybe a simpler partitioning of purposes would be:
- Do you think it should be about concertinas?
- Do you think it should be about concertinas we own?
- Do you think it should be about concertinas we play?
#14
Posted 06 March 2012 - 02:31 AM
Tony
#15
Posted 06 March 2012 - 08:54 AM






Edited by kevin toner, 06 March 2012 - 11:24 AM.
#16
Posted 06 March 2012 - 10:23 AM
Same issue here, Kevin...all of your image files are in a private gallery, so they can't be linked to another site.
Since Kevin has since fixed the issue, I'm editing my comment to reflect that.
Edited by Reed Bellows, 06 March 2012 - 12:06 PM.
#17
Posted 06 March 2012 - 11:26 AM
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users











