Jump to content

wayman

Members
  • Content count

    278
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About wayman

  • Rank
    Chatty concertinist

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Not Telling
  • Interests
    ethnomusicology, organology, boulliabaseball
  • Location
    Sheffield, UK

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. wayman

    Sessions In London

    Also, here's the Folk London Club Guide (last updated a few weeks ago, so seems to be well-curated and likely reliable!).
  2. wayman

    Sessions In London

    First Sunday (so, the 3rd of June this year) at the Horseshoe, from noon to three or so. This session had maybe half a dozen concertinas of all systems, plus me and Jim Besser, last June. Very friendly and welcoming, great tunes (if you like English tunes!).
  3. wayman

    Reed Chamber Length Experiment

    I think the Dipper baritone I looked at had differently-sized pad holes, and I made measurements / notes about this, though I don't think I did experimentation about how this affects reed response... and I hadn't even considered the possibility of a differently-shaped hole (so the same amount of air can travel through it, while none of it gets too much of a "head start" towards the tip end of the reed). Nice insight, and I'd love to see whether that idea bears fruit. Another project for someday, if you don't experiment with it first... 🙂 W
  4. wayman

    Reed Chamber Length Experiment

    Good spot, Adrian. This would corroborate my findings that the length of air travel made more difference than the total size of the chamber in the ESB prototypes... Okay, it seems like I will have a new hobby the next time I'm back in the UK where my test bellows live, Dana! Not quite as crazy as the guy who carried a piano up Ben Nevis, but definitely a bit out of the ordinary... It'll give me a good excuse to do some hill climbing 🙂 W
  5. wayman

    Reed Chamber Length Experiment

    Dana, that's brilliant! I love it! In the 38-key Jeffries, there's a button on the left which is Bb below middle C on the draw and Bb an octave higher on the push. They never feel or sound quite the same, and I've always wished I had a solution to that. I don't really want to monkey with a Jeffries reedpan in that way, but I'll keep this in mind for future efforts of my own.
  6. wayman

    Reed Chamber Length Experiment

    Now I want to take a test bellows and variable-chamber-size jig and various reeds to different altitudes (with greatly different air pressures) and collect lots more data! 😎 Imagine the other mountain climbers wondering what the heck you're doing up there, when you get to the summit and set up your test bellows... 😆
  7. wayman

    Reed Chamber Length Experiment

    Frank, is it strictly the size of the chamber (the volume of air in the chamber) that makes the difference? In my experience, if the chamber is longer than the reed, but the tip of the reed isn't all the way at the one end of the chamber and the pad hole isn't all the way at the other end of the chamber, the extra length of the chamber doesn't make nearly as much difference, no matter how much longer it is. That makes me think it's less about the volume of air in the chamber - and hence air pressure, though that may be a distinct factor - as about how far the air travels. But because the physical dimensions of the concertina are a limiting factor (if you want to keep it to a 6 1/4 or 7 inch instrument), sometimes making the chamber deeper is the only way to enlarge the chamber, and that does make some difference, just not as great a difference.
  8. wayman

    Reed Chamber Length Experiment

    I've got reedpans for a large Wheatstone Maccann from the 1920s, and reedpans for a Lachenal baritone anglo from who knows when, where on the left side, the plane of the reedpan is not parallel to the plane of the action board: the chambers get progressively deeper from the end with the higher notes to the end with the lower notes, and it's a pretty big difference (the lowest chambers are probably 1/4 or 3/8 inch deeper than the highest chambers). I've never seen this done on the right side reedpan of a Maccann or anglo, though that's perhaps because the reeds are a bit less "in pitch order" on the reedpan. But on my G/D Jeffries, a previous owner (Robin, this was you who did this, right?) shortened the chamber of one of the highest reeds on the right side by filling the back end of the chamber with blu-tac, and that does seem to increase the response of the reed! (There's a thread here, from about five or six years ago, where Robin and Adrian discuss this at some length.)
  9. wayman

    Reed Chamber Length Experiment

    (I then used these findings to redesign the reedpan for the Georgie baritone (English) model, lengthening as many of the chambers as we could make space for, and it dramatically improved the response of the lowest half-octave of that instrument! So these experiments with chamber length are very worthwhile.)
  10. wayman

    Reed Chamber Length Experiment

    Very nice jig, Alex! I made something very similar when the Button Box was designing the Morse ESB (baritone anglo model), and then took the data I gathered (on lengths that seemed to work well in practice for various pitches) and tried to come up with an algorithm that described the data. I recall getting somewhere roughly with that, but given that I'd already done the empirical research which definitely worked on a prototype reedpan, there wasn't really a need to perfect an algorithm. This (as demonstrated in instruments on three successive full prototype reedpan designs with different chamber lengths) made an enormous difference in the performance and sound of the instrument. I was guided by a Dipper baritone that had conveniently come in for repairs just as I was starting to think about ideal chamber lengths for reeds. I measured its chambers; the one thing I remember is that there were (unsurprisingly) some differences in actual length / air volume for chambers that seemed to work with hybrid vs concertina reeds, but also (unsurprisingly) the trend in each was pretty similar in the ratios of air volumes between pitches.
  11. wayman

    2-button tunes on Anglo?

    Folk music is rarely as simple as many people think it is! I simplified my explanation of the "three melodic notes" to "scale tones 1,2,3 of a minor scale" just to quickly describe the melody but you're right, technically it's NOT that, and whatever it is, the "complicated whatever" is what makes the Watersons' recording so good. I want to sit down with this at some point and figure out what the Watersons are actually doing sometime. The simpler the tune, the more varied the ways you can mess around with harmonies... Another three-note tune (maybe song? are there lyrics?) that's similar (at least thematically in title) is "Hot Cross Buns", which might be Suzuki book 1 tune 1 or 2, one of those things kids learn at age three and then never play again.... Christian religious baked goods seem to get celebrated with three-note melodies for whatever reason!!! (Anyone know a three-note song about communion wafers?) For a Christian religious baked goods song with many more notes in the melody, seek out Rosie Hood's recording of "Baker's Oven" (the only recording I or Mainly Norfolk know of this song; lyrics here though to hear it I think you'll have to buy the album or song, or better still hear Rosie live sometime - all worthwhile experiences, especially if you catch her current dual-bill tour with Cohen Braithwaite-Kilcoyne, to work some concertina content into this post).
  12. wayman

    2-button tunes on Anglo?

    A soul, a soul, a soul cake, Please, good missus, a soul cake, An apple, a pear, a plum or a cherry, Any good thing to make us merry. One for Peter, two for Paul, Three for Him that made us all. (As sung by the Watersons) It's just the first three notes of the minor scale. Six years ago I handed John Roberts a toy concertina with zero buttons, rubber bellows, and one diatonic reed on each side, just to see what he'd do with it. This was at the intermission of a Nowell Sing We Clear performance, in the theatre lobby. And he immediately launched into the souling song, and it was perfect.
  13. It's a way to play concertina and shakey-egg at the same time!
  14. wayman

    Pop Up Ads

    I'm curious what the economics of some other comparable instrument-focused or folk-music-oriented online forums are, which feature similar discussions among like-minded communities. Melnet, Mandolin Café, Chiff & Fipple, Banjo Hangout, Fiddle Forum ... and places like the Session and Mudcat, too ... are any of them paying north of $1000 pa for their forum software? If so, where does the money come from? If not, what other forum software(s) are they using, what are their annual costs, and would cnet gain or lose functionality if it switched to any of those other platforms?
  15. wayman

    Pop Up Ads

    I can't imagine anyone visiting this site clicking on the ads that have been observed or described so far... it's unclear to me what this accomplishes for anyone. Don refers to "paying members". Are there paying members? I'd never even known that was an option! What does it mean to be a paying member, how does one do it (or even discover one can do it), and are there benefits (besides knowing you're supporting a worthy website and, potentially, avoiding ads)?
×